For pool owners and backyard enthusiasts, choosing the right equipment is crucial to ensuring a well-maintained, efficient, and enjoyable swimming experience. Two of the most prominent names in the pool industry are Pentair and Hayward. Both companies offer a wide range of products, including pumps, filters, heaters, pool cleaners, and automation systems. But when it comes to deciding who is truly better, the answer depends on what you value most: performance, energy efficiency, durability, price, or service availability.
In this article, we will dive deep into the Pentair vs. Hayward debate, comparing key product lines, features, pricing, user experiences, and technical performance. Whether you’re building a new pool, renovating an older one, or just looking for the best pool equipment for maintenance, this guide will provide the insights you need to make an informed decision.
Overview of Pentair and Hayward
Before jumping into product specifics, let’s establish a basic understanding of both companies.
Who Is Pentair?
Pentair is a global company that has been in the pool equipment industry for decades. Initially known as a broader water treatment and control systems provider, it has become a dominant name in the residential swimming pool space. The company’s tagline, “We bring water to life,” reflects its focus on water quality, filtration, and smart pool technology. Pentair’s product lineup includes energy-efficient pumps, saltwater chlorinators, LED lighting, and pool automation systems.
Who Is Hayward?
Hayward Industries, headquartered in New Jersey, is another major player in the pool and spa equipment market. Founded in 1910, the company started with a focus on filtration systems and has since expanded into every sector of the pool industry—from pool heaters and pumps to automatic pool cleaners and sanitization systems. Hayward emphasizes innovation, durability, and ease of use, targeting both residential and commercial customers.
Product Categories: Key Areas of Comparison
To make this comparison objective and meaningful, we’ll break it down into the most essential types of pool equipment:
- Pumps
- Filters
- Pool Heaters
- Chlorinators
- Automation Systems
We’ll evaluate each product category based on five key criteria: performance efficiency, energy savings, durability, ease of use/maintenance, and pricing.
1. Pumps
Let’s start with the heart of most pool systems: the pool pump.
Pentair Pumps
Pentair offers both single-speed and variable-speed pumps with a clear emphasis on energy efficiency in its newer models, especially the SuperFlo VS and IntelliFlo VS series. These pumps are often ENERGY STAR certified and designed to significantly lower electricity usage—sometimes by over 90% compared to older single-speed models. Their IntelliFlo line includes programmable timers and remote access via smart platforms.
Hayward Pumps
On the other side, Hayward’s Super Pump and Ecostar VS stand out. The Ecostar series is particularly praised for its ultra-efficient design and whisper-quiet operation. It also carries ENERGY STAR certification and is compatible with automation systems. Hayward’s pumps are considered more traditional in design and are known for reliable performance.
Comparison Table: Pumps
| Feature | Pentair | Hayward |
|---|---|---|
| Energy Efficiency | High, especially in IntelliFlo series | Extremely high in Ecostar models |
| Smart Compatibility | Yes, via Pentair Automation | Yes, via Hayward OmniLogic/OMNI Control |
| Pricing (mid-range models) | $400–$800 | $450–$900 |
| Noise Level | Lower in VS models | Very low |
| Customizability | High | Moderate to high |
Verdict:
Hayward edges out slightly in terms of pure energy savings and noise levels with the EcoStar VS, but Pentair wins in smart feature integration and user customization. If you’re using an automation system, Pentair offers more seamless compatibility.
2. Filters
Filters are another cornerstone of clean water. There are three main types: sand, DE (diatomaceous earth), and cartridge. Both Pentair and Hayward offer all three, but with distinct advantages and disadvantages.
Pentair Filters
Pentair’s Clean & Clear Cartridge and ProGrid DE filters are recognized for their ease of cleaning and long lifespan. Their cartridge models are often lighter and easier to service than Hayward’s for residential users. Pentair’s stainless-steel top-port design allows for easy direction changes during installation.
Hayward Filters
Hayward’s ProSeries Sand Filters are some of the most popular in the industry for mid to high-volume applications. They boast high dirt-holding capacity. Their NutraGrid DE options offer fine filtration (down to 2 microns) and are known for consistent performance.
Comparison Table: Filters
| Feature | Pentair | Hayward |
|---|---|---|
| Cartridge Filters | Easy to maintain, long filter life | Moderate ease; average lifespan |
| DE Filters | High performance, slightly less user-friendly | Extremely fine filtration, more extensive maintenance |
| Sand Filters | Good, standard performance | Excellent flow capacity, reliable at medium cost |
| Pressure Release Efficiency | Moderate | Higher |
| Installation Ease | Better with top-mount valves | Reliable, but traditional side-plumbing |
Verdict:
Hayward is known to have the slight advantage in filtration performance, especially in commercial-grade setups, but for most homeowners, Pentair offers a more user-friendly design and less labor-intensive filter maintenance. Ease of backwashing also often favors Pentair in smaller residential applications.
3. Pool Heaters (Gas & Heat Pumps)
Having a heater is essential for extending the swim season, and choosing the right brand can affect both performance and operating cost.
Pentair Heaters
Pentair is recognized for its MastRay and Mastiff gas heater lines which are praised for durability and fast heating. They offer units from 200,000 to over 400,000 BTUs. They also have heat pump options like the UltraTemp Heat Pump, which are efficient but dependent on outdoor air temperatures.
Hayward Heaters
Hayward’s Universal H-Series (gas) and HeatPro Heat Pumps offer strong performance with higher energy savings in heat pump configurations. Their Universal H-Series gas heaters have a stainless steel heat exchanger and are ENERGY STAR certified, which improves operating cost efficiency significantly.
Comparison Table: Pool Heaters
| Feature | Pentair | Hayward |
|---|---|---|
| Gas Heater Efficiency | High BTU range with solid build | Very High, especially with heat exchanger design |
| Heat Pump Efficiency | High COP (>5) | Higher COP (>6 under ideal conditions) |
| Corrosion Resistance | Polymer models available | Stainless steel is standard on higher-end models |
| Maintenance Cost | Moderate | Moderate to high (especially DE-compatible heaters) |
| Control Precision | With Pentair controls | With Hayward automation systems |
Verdict:
Hayward tends to offer a better long-term investment for efficiency and corrosion resistance in their high-end gas and heat pump models. Pentair isn’t far behind and may suit better if integrated with their wider automation suite.
4. Chlorinators (Saltwater Systems)
Salt systems are a favorite for residential pool owners due to their low chemical handling and better water feel.
Pentair Salt Chlorinators
Pentair’s Intellichlor series is designed to work seamlessly with Pentair pump and filter systems. Intellichlor units have digital interfaces and self-diagnostic capabilities, making them easy to monitor. Their low-flow alerts, built-in diagnostics, and long cell lifespan make them a favorite among professionals.
Hayward Salt Chlorinators
Hayward’s AQR series is often found on a wide variety of home pools. The AQR14 vs AQR20 models scale well with common pool sizes. These units are generally cost-effective but may not last as long as Pentair’s under high usage.
Comparison Table: Salt Chlorinators
| Feature | Pentair | Hayward |
|---|---|---|
| Cell Longevity | Typically 5+ years | 3–5 years average |
| Installation Complexity | Moderate to easy with compatible systems | Generally easy |
| Self-Cleaning Features | Yes, built-in | Limited; mostly manual |
| Operational Cost (Over Five Years) | Low | Moderate to low |
| Integration | Better with Pentair pumps | Strong standalone compatibility |
Verdict:
When it comes to longevity and user experience, Pentair wins again. Its Intellichlor systems may cost more upfront, but the reduced need for replacements and better diagnostics can make them more cost-effective in the long run, especially for larger or frequently used pools.
5. Automation and Smart Pool Controls
Automation is the key to convenience in modern pool ownership, especially for tech-focused homeowners who value energy efficiency and control.
Pentair Automation
Pentair leads the smart pool movement with its EasyTouch and ScreenLogic2 controls. These allow full system integration for pumps, heaters, chlorinators, lights, and even water features. The Pentair Mobile App is regarded as one of the best in the industry for pool automation, offering advanced scheduling and diagnostic features.
Hayward Automation
Hayward’s automation comes under the OMNILogic and OMNI Control system, which also provides comprehensive control over pool equipment and even spas. However, users often note that its interface isn’t quite as polished or intuitive as Pentair’s. In recent years though, Hayward has improved their cloud-based access and mobile app responsiveness.
Comparison Table: Automation Systems
| Feature | Pentair | Hayward |
|---|---|---|
| Mobility (App Interface) | Best in class | Good but occasionally lagging |
| Scheduling Flexibility | Very high | Moderate to high |
| Energy Monitoring | Real-time tracking | Basic usage reports |
| Integration Options | Built-in compatibility with all Pentair units | Cross-brand compatibility better than Pentair |
| Setup Complexity | Moderate | Easy for non-experts |
Verdict:
Pentair dominates this category with superior app integration, energy-saving features, and smoother user interface. However, Hayward may be preferred by customers who are not using exclusively Hayward equipment and want a system that integrates with third-party systems.
Reliability and Warranty Comparison
A product is only as strong as the support and warranty behind it. It’s essential to consider reliability and customer support when purchasing pool equipment.
Pentair
Pentair offers warranties ranging from 1 to 5+ years depending on the product. Their IntelliFlo VS pump and Intellichlor systems often come with a 3–5-year warranty. Pentair is known for reliable customer service and strong dealer/distributor support, though service times can vary depending on your region.
Hayward
Hayward provides similar warranty structures for most products (2–5 years). Their warranty coverage often includes specific terms based on proper installation and regular maintenance logs. Consumers note that Hayward’s customer service response times can be slower, but their parts availability is very good across North America.
Conclusion: Both offer competitive warranties, but Pentair receives an edge for customer service satisfaction.
Cost Analysis and Value for Money
Now let’s compare these two titans in terms of upfront cost, long-term expense, and overall value.
Pricing Comparison
Both companies’ products are priced comparably, though Pentair tends to be slightly more expensive when purchasing bundled systems or high-end automation packages. However, Pentair often justifies this with better warranties and energy efficiency that reduces long-term costs.
Long-Term Cost Considerations
| Factor | Pentair | Hayward |
|——————————-|—————————————-|—————————————-|
| Energy Efficiency | Higher (saves over time) | High |
| Parts Replacement Frequency | Lower (durable components) | Slightly more frequent on some models |
| Automation Compatibility | High (reduces labor for homeowners) | Moderate |
| Maintenance Complexity | User-friendly | Varies by model |
Verdict: Both companies offer long-term value, but for pools that rely heavily on energy efficiency and smart control integration, Pentair is more cost-effective.
Pros and Cons Summary
Pentair Pros
- Superior energy-efficient models
- Best-in-class pool automation and app control
- Extended warranty and service options
- Long-lasting chlorinator systems
Pentair Cons
- Higher starter price for top-tier products
- Slightly less compatibility with third-party systems
Hayward Pros
- More competitively priced for standard models
- Excellent performance in basic to mid-range models
- Better ease of maintenance for standard pool setups
- Strong third-party compatibility
Hayward Cons
- Automation platform can feel outdated compared to Pentair
- Some models have shorter lifespans (especially salt systems)
Final Recommendation: Who’s Better?
Ultimately, the better brand depends on your individual pool and preferences:
-
If you value smart integration, energy efficiency, and less-frequent maintenance, Pentair is the better choice. It offers premium systems that are designed with future homeowners in mind.
-
If you’re focused on cost-efficiency, ease of maintenance, and third-party compatibility, especially if you already use non-Hayward equipment, Hayward might serve you better, especially in sand filter and lower-end automation setups.
Both Pentair and Hayward provide high-quality products and have stood the test of time in the industry. Your decision will likely come down to your pool’s size, your climate, and whether you’re investing more in initial installation or long-term performance and savings.
Conclusion
So, who comes out on top between Pentair vs. Hayward? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but when it comes to technology, automation, and energy efficiency, Pentair has a slight edge. Meanwhile, Hayward takes the lead in cost-effectiveness and broader compatibility. Whether you side with one or the other, either brand offers a reliable and proven path to a cleaner, more enjoyable pool.
What factors should I consider when choosing between Pentair and Hayward pool equipment?
When comparing Pentair and Hayward, several key factors should guide your decision: product quality, energy efficiency, pricing, warranty, and customer support. Pentair is often praised for its innovative, energy-efficient designs and durable construction, which may result in higher upfront costs but potentially lower long-term expenses. Hayward, on the other hand, is known for offering a broad range of products that cater to different budgets, with a strong presence in both premium and mid-tier markets.
Additionally, the type of pool equipment you need—whether pumps, filters, heaters, or automation systems—can influence which brand suits you best. Pentair’s strengths lie particularly in its integrated systems like the EasyTouch and IntelliTouch controllers, which offer seamless automation and smart home compatibility. Hayward also offers robust automation solutions such as the OMNISTAR system, often with slightly lower price points. Your decision should ultimately depend on your budget, pool size, and specific equipment needs.
Which brand is more energy-efficient, Pentair or Hayward?
Pentair has developed a strong reputation for energy-efficient equipment, especially with its variable speed pumps such as the Pentair SuperFlo VS and IntelliFlo models. These pumps are designed to adapt to the specific needs of the pool, significantly reducing energy consumption and operational costs over time. The brand’s focus on eco-friendly innovations often positions it slightly ahead in terms of energy savings for pool owners looking to reduce utility bills.
Hayward also offers a solid lineup of energy-efficient products, including the EcoStar VS pump, which is one of the most energy-efficient variable speed pumps available on the market. While both brands meet Energy Star standards and deliver strong energy-saving capabilities, Pentair’s advanced motor technology and more intuitive control systems often give it a minor edge in efficiency ratings. However, energy savings will also depend on local electricity rates and how the equipment is used.
How do the warranties of Pentair and Hayward compare?
Pentair provides competitive warranties across its product lines, especially for its high-end pumps and automation systems. For example, the Pentair IntelliFlo pump comes with a 3-year warranty, and some of its control systems may offer extended coverage when registered. Pentair’s warranties are generally seen as reliable, with straightforward claims processing, provided that the equipment is installed and maintained correctly.
Hayward also offers strong warranty protection, with most of its top-tier pumps carrying 1- to 3-year warranties. For instance, the Hayward Super Pump has a 1-year warranty, while the more advanced models like the Dual Glide II filter offer longer coverage periods. Hayward’s warranties are often considered comparable to Pentair’s but may vary depending on the product category and model. Customers should also consider registering their products promptly to ensure full warranty benefits.
Are Pentair and Hayward compatible with smart pool systems?
Both Pentair and Hayward offer smart pool technology that allows homeowners to control and monitor their pool equipment remotely via mobile apps. Pentair’s ecosystem includes the EasyTouch and IntelliTouch controllers, which integrate seamlessly with the Pentair Mobile app, enabling users to manage filtration, heating, cleaning, and lighting from their smartphones. These systems are lauded for their user-friendly interface and compatibility with leading smart home systems like Alexa and Google Assistant.
Hayward’s OMNISTAR system offers similar smart functionality through the Hayward AquaRite app and OMNIlogic Plus platform, which allows users to monitor and adjust pool settings from a mobile device. Although slightly less intuitive than Pentair’s approach, Hayward’s system is robust and offers extensive control options, especially for multi-system pools. Both brands have made significant investments in smart technology, making either a viable choice depending on your preference for interface and ecosystem integration.
Which brand offers better customer support, Pentair or Hayward?
Pentair is often credited with having strong customer service, particularly regarding technical support and troubleshooting. The brand provides extensive online resources, including installation videos, manuals, and troubleshooting guides. Their customer support team is generally responsive, though some users have reported long wait times during busy pool seasons.
Hayward also has a solid reputation for customer support, with comprehensive product documentation and a national network of authorized dealers who offer servicing and repairs. Some users prefer Hayward for the accessibility of their local distributors, which can make obtaining replacement parts and professional service easier in some regions. Ultimately, both companies provide adequate support, but experiences can vary depending on your location and the complexity of the issue.
Which brand has a better selection of pool pumps?
Pentair offers a wide variety of pool pumps with a particular emphasis on variable speed and smart-enabled models. The IntelliFlo VS pump is known for its energy efficiency, quiet operation, and precise flow control. Their pumps are often preferred by those seeking high performance and customization, especially when integrated with Pentair’s automation systems.
Hayward’s pump lineup includes both single-speed and variable speed models and is widely recognized for the reliability and durability of its Super Pump series. The EcoStar VS is Hayward’s flagship variable speed model and offers strong efficiency and versatility. While both brands offer quality pumps, Hayward tends to provide a slightly broader range of budget-friendly options, whereas Pentair excels in innovation and high-end performance.
Do Pentair or Hayward parts last longer, and which is easier to service?
Pentair parts are generally known for their durability, especially in their higher-end models. The build quality of their pumps, filters, and heaters supports longer service life, particularly when regularly maintained. However, because Pentair products can be more technologically advanced, repairs may require specialized knowledge or components, which might affect the ease of servicing in some cases.
Hayward equipment is widely regarded for being easier to service and maintain, thanks to its straightforward designs and widespread availability of replacement parts. With a large distribution network and many authorized dealers across the country, finding the right technician or parts is typically less of a challenge for Hayward owners. Both brands offer lasting parts, but if serviceability is a priority, Hayward might have an edge for the average pool owner.