When it comes to maximizing the enjoyment and safety of your backyard pool, pool screening plays a crucial role. Not only does it protect your pool area from insects and debris, but it also helps prevent accidental falls and keeps out unwanted pests. However, with a wide range of options available—from DIY nets to fully enclosed pool cages—the question of what is the best pool screening can be a complex one to answer.
This article explores the top pool screening options currently available, their pros and cons, and how to make an informed decision based on your lifestyle, climate, budget, and maintenance preferences.
The Importance of Pool Screening
Before diving into the best options, it’s essential to understand why pool screening matters. Whether you have a traditional in-ground pool, an above-ground model, or a luxury pool spa, having a protective barrier serves multiple purposes:
- Enhances safety for children and pets
- Reduces pool maintenance by keeping out leaves, dirt, and bugs
- Minimizes algae growth by limiting sunlight exposure
- Keeps mosquitoes and other insects out of the water area
- Can increase the usability of your pool during windy or cold weather
Investing in the right pool screen system is not only about convenience—it’s about protecting your valuable investment. With so many types of pool screening systems on the market, you want to choose one that aligns perfectly with your needs and expectations.
Types of Pool Screening: An Overview
To identify the best pool screening for your use case, it’s important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of different types of pool coverings:
1. Mesh Pool Covers
Mechanically reinforced mesh covers are a popular choice for seasonal pool coverage, especially during colder months.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| ✅ Durable and resistant to weather elements | ❌ Can trap rainwater if not properly installed |
| ✅ UV-resistant material | ❌ May allow small debris through |
| ✅ Strong and long-lasting | ❌ Can be time-consuming to install and remove |
These covers are often anchored around the edges and may feature drains to help with water runoff. They’re most commonly used in residential pools and are recommended by professionals for long-term pool closure.
2. Automatic Pool Covers
Pricier but highly convenient, automatic covers roll out and retract with the push of a button.
Key features:
- ✔️ Controlled by electric motor or manual crank
- ✔️ Offer excellent safety by sealing the pool surface
- ✔️ Ideal for families with small children
Since they operate so smoothly, automatic pool covers enhance pool heating and chemical retention. In climates with long swim seasons, these systems provide the ultimate in usability and reliability. Although this is an investment at $5,000 to $20,000 range, depending on size and brand, they often qualify for local rebates or pool safety incentives.
3. Solid Pool Covers (Tarpaulin Style)
Also known as winter pool covers, solid plastic covers create a full barrier over the pool’s surface. While they do an exceptional job at blocking sunlight and keeping debris out, they must be paired with proper water chemistry and an automatic cover pump to drain standing water.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| ✅ Excellent debris and evaporation protection | ❌ Traps water unless pumps are used |
| ✅ Cost-effective compared to other systems | ❌ Not as safe as mesh or automatic covers |
This pool screening is best suited for seasonal closure, particularly in northern regions where the pool is closed for several months a year.
4. Pool Safety Nets
For those who prefer less permanent solutions, safety nets provide a lightweight, customizable screening option.
They usually feature:
- Mesh panels supported by cords anchored around the pool perimeter
- Easy to install and remove as needed
- Can withstand weight from children or pets without tearing
Compared to solid covers, they allow some debris to pass through—especially fine particles like dust and pollen—but they are ideal for families with children under 5 years old.
5. Full Pool Enclosures (Screen Rooms, Pool Cages, Verandas)
For an all-season solution with unmatched protection, full pool enclosures are becoming increasingly popular in regions like Florida and the Southwest.
This category includes:
- Aluminum-framed screened-in porches for pools
- Enclosed sunrooms with solid roofs made of polycarbonate or glass
- Retractable shade or mesh systems around a pool area
Pool enclosures serve multiple purposes: they shield from insects, reduce evaporation, provide UV protection, and can even increase property value. However, their price tag is significant, and in some jurisdictions, permits are required.
What Makes a Pool Screening the Best?
Finding the best pool screening involves factoring in several variables. Here are the main criteria to evaluate based on your personal situation.
Pool Size and Shape
The physical dimensions of your pool dictate what types of screening systems you can install. Smaller above-ground pools may benefit from low-cost mesh covers, whereas larger pools might require custom-built aluminum enclosures or motorized safety covers to ensure proper fit and function.
Climate and Seasonality
Where you live determines the type of pool enclosure you’ll need year-round care for or whether you’ll need a winter or summer-specific screen.
- In colder climates, solid covers or thermal pool blankets are ideal.
- In the Sun Belt, mesh pool cages or retractable automatic covers are more practical.
- If mosquito season is long and severe, full mesh enclosure or screening rooms offer the best defense.
Budget
There’s a wide range of pool screening systems available across every budget level. Consider:
- Low-budget options: DIY pool netting ($500–$1,000)
- Moderate investment: Mesh safety covers ($1,000–$4,000)
- High-end: Automatic covers and custom pool cages ($5,000–$25,000+)
Keep in mind that higher cost items often last longer and reduce maintenance and heating expenses in the long term.
Aesthetics and Design Preference
Some pool screening systems are visible from public areas of your home. If you value landscape beauty alongside pool functionality, then selecting a low-profile cover or an architecturally designed pool cage with colors and textures matching your home’s exterior might be ideal.
Patio pool covers that can double as poolside lounges or shade structures may suit homeowners who host parties or enjoy spending time poolside.
Installation and Maintenance Needs
Consider the effort involved in putting up and taking down a screen. Automatic systems and pool enclosures require professional installation, whereas mesh pool nets or solid covers can generally be applied and removed quickly by the homeowner.
Periodic cleaning, storage, and inspections are necessary for all pool covers. For instance, automatic covers must be lubricated and powered checks conducted, whereas mesh nets may need re-tensioning and tightening after storms.
Safety and Compliance
In many regions, pool safety is required by law—especially for families with young children. In locations like Florida or California, specific safety requirements mandate pool enclosures to meet certain structural and durability standards.
Always verify that your pool screening solution:
- Meets the ASTM safety standards
- Can support up to 400 pounds for safety nets
- Is certified for safety features where applicable
Top Pool Screening Solutions Reviewed
Let’s now look at specific systems or brands that have consistently ranked as the best pool screening options based on customer feedback, technical performance, and safety credentials.
1. Water Warden Mesh Pool Safety Net – Top for Cost-Effective Protection
This brand offers custom-made, heavy-duty mesh screens with tensioned anchor cables, built-in water drains, and removable center panels for access.
What users love:
- Easy manual removal without tools
- Discreet appearance when installed
- Safe for kids and pets
Water Warden is frequently cited by lifeguard teams and safety organizations. Ideal for in-ground pools, it can also be adapted to above-ground pools in certain configurations.
2. Coverstar Rolling Pool Covers – High-End Automatic Systems
Coverstar offers premium motorized and manual automatic pool covers. They are ideal for heated pools, particularly in the Southwest and southern areas of the U.S.
| Why It Stands Out | Customer Concerns |
|---|---|
| ✔️ Energy and heat retention | ❌ Higher installation cost ($7,000–$20,000+) |
| ✔️ Strong safety rating | ❌ Must be professional installed |
These systems offer a high level of convenience and are recommended by pool technicians to significantly reduce chemical and water loss.
3. ScreenShade Retractable Pool Screens – Versatile for Outdoor Use
Perfect for pool decks, terraces, and patios, the ScreenShade system features retractable mesh panels that can be hidden when not needed. These are often used in residential and luxury resort-style pools.
Its main benefits include:
- Offers insect-free lounging area
- Blocks up to 90% of UV light
- Can be motorized for added ease of use
While originally developed for commercial facilities, it’s gaining traction among homeowners who want to make a year-round outdoor room.
4. PoolGuard Mesh Covers – Residential Mesh Cover Champion
PoolGuard is a leading name in winter mesh covers, emphasizing durability and affordability.
Their mesh cover has reinforced webbing and is designed to lock into anchors that are drilled around the pool edge. These covers are breathable (to avoid water trapping), yet prevent large debris and rodents from getting into covered pools.
Key Selling Points:
- ✅ Easy to remove for spring startup
- ✅ Resists tearing and wind uplift
- ✅ Custom-fitted for any irregular pool shape
Ideal for colder seasonal zones, though not recommended for constant daily use.
The Best Pool Screening for Different Use Cases
To help you decide based on real-life circumstances, let’s break down the best pool screenings for specific user profiles and situations.
For Busy Families with Small Children
If safety is your top concern, automatic pool covers or mesh safety nets are the top options. Their ability to provide a solid visual and physical barrier helps prevent accidents and keeps adults peace of mind.
Top choice: Coverstar or Water Warden Safety Net
- Meets ASTM safety standards
- Easy to operate (automatic covers), or very sturdy
- High load-bearing for safety
For Swimming Enthusiasts in Warmer Climates
For year-round pools in sun-heavy areas (like Phoenix or Miami), consider a fully enclosed screen room or retractable privacy pool screen.
Recommended option: Custom Aluminum Enclosure or ScreenShade Retractable Pool Screen
- Pest control with a cool lounging area
- Effective heat & evaporation control
- Extends pool deck usability
For Seasonal Pools in Northern Zones
If your pool only opens 3–5 months per year, a UV-stabilized mesh cover or heavy-duty solid pool cover can prolong the life of your water balance and reduce the hassle during closing and startup.
Top choice: PoolGuard Heavy Mesh or WinterPro Solid Tarps
- Excellent price-to-performance ratio
- Helps winterize with minimal labor
- Protects from leaves, sticks, wildlife
For Budget-Conscious Homeowners
DreamClear DIY Pool Safety Netting Systems
There are more affordable pool safety options like DIY mesh kits which can be self-installed for under $1,500. While less robust than manufacturer-stamped systems, these kits still provide considerable safety for smaller families with fewer maintenance concerns.
Pros:
- ✅ Easy home installation
- ✅ Cost less than professional alternatives
- ✅ Custom-fit instructions included
However, these systems may require annual replacement depending on exposure to harsh conditions.
Maintenance Tips for Long-Lasting Pool Screens
After you’ve invested in the best pool screening, maintaining it ensures longevity and optimal performance. Whether it’s a mesh cover, retractable panel or a safety net, here are some maintenance best practices:
Inspect for Wear and Tear Regularly
Use monthly checks, especially after storms or wind events, to ensure no rips, tears, or anchor failures.
Clean Debris Promptly
For mesh nets or screens, remove leaves and debris regularly with a soft brush—not a pressure washer, which could compromise the material.
Ensure Proper Water Drainage
If using mesh covers, ensure that drain lines are unobstructed to prevent pooling water, which adds stress to the screen.
Lubricate Moving Parts Annually
For automatic rolls and retractable systems, adding recommended lubricants to tracks and mechanisms yearly helps avoid corrosion and mechanical noise.
Replace Worn Sections Proactively
Some covers allow section replacement rather than full system updates, especially custom mesh nets like Water Warden or PoolGuard.
Store Covers Smartly in Off-Season
If you remove your cover for summer, store it in a dry, shaded area, rolled or folded with clean cloths between layers to avoid mold or mildew.
Conclusion: Choosing the Best Pool Screening for You
The best pool screening depends on your unique needs—it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. When making this decision, consider:
- Budget – whether you’re investing for a season or the lifetime of the pool
- Climate – how long and how harsh the off-seasons are
- Safety Level – whether children or pets use the space
- Usage Frequency – how often the pool is used and the expected wear
- Maintenance Preferences – whether you prefer a hands-off or cost-conscious approach
From budget-friendly mesh nets to top-of-the-line aluminum enclosures, each screening option has distinct advantages. For most suburban American homeowners, a well-fitted mesh safety net or a mesh winter cover offers the best value and utility without compromising on safety.
But if you’re looking for a luxury feature that enhances both aesthetic appeal and usability, investing in an integrated pool enclosure like a retractable screen system or automated pool cover would be ideal.
Carefully assess your lifestyle and long-term goals, and don’t forget to consult with professionals or reputable pool retailers for tailored product insights based on your exact pool model and region.
About the Author
This guide was crafted by expert pool technicians and digital content writers who have been covering residential pool maintenance and safety topics for over a decade. Their focus remains on delivering accurate, insightful, and practical guidance to homeowners looking to protect and maximize the value of their pools. Whether it’s above-ground or in-ground, saltwater or chlorinated, this team offers advice grounded in real-world applications and consumer needs.
What are pool screens and why are they important?
Pool screens are protective enclosures designed to surround swimming pools, offering a barrier against debris, insects, and harmful UV rays. They are typically made from durable, weather-resistant mesh materials that allow for airflow while maintaining visibility. These screens are essential for pool owners who want to keep their pool clean, reduce maintenance costs, and enhance safety by preventing accidental falls into the pool, especially for children and pets.
In addition to safety and cleanliness, pool screens contribute to extending the usability of your pool by shielding swimmers from wind and sun. They also help in minimizing water evaporation and chemical loss due to sun exposure. Whether you are looking to protect your investment or simply enjoy a more comfortable swimming experience, pool screens are a practical and versatile solution that can be customized to fit a variety of pool shapes and sizes.
How do I determine the right type of pool screen for my needs?
Choosing the right pool screen depends on several factors, including your climate, pool size and shape, intended use, and aesthetic preferences. If you live in an area with high winds or intense sun exposure, you may benefit from a heavy-duty enclosure with reinforced frames and UV-resistant mesh. For regions with mild weather, a lighter, more portable screen may suffice. It’s also important to assess whether you want a fully enclosed structure or a retractable option that allows you the flexibility to open the pool area when desired.
Another key consideration is the material used in the screen. Mesh screens are popular for their durability and visibility, while solid covers might be preferred for areas requiring more insulation or privacy. Some pool owners also look into screened-in lanais or patio enclosures if they desire a more integrated and permanent solution. Consulting with a professional installer can help determine the specific needs for your pool and guide you toward the best type of enclosure.
What are the benefits of retractable pool screens compared to fixed ones?
Retractable pool screens offer the flexibility of being opened or closed depending on the weather and your preferences. This feature allows for greater control over sunlight, airflow, and temperature regulation around the pool area. Retractable systems are ideal for homeowners who enjoy an open-air feel but still want the option to protect against insects and UV rays when needed. These screens can easily be deployed or stowed away, making them a convenient solution for seasonal changes or special events.
In contrast, fixed pool screens are permanent structures that fully enclose the pool area and require a more involved installation. While they offer consistent protection and often a more polished appearance, they may limit natural airflow and access. Retractable screens, on the other hand, are considered a versatile middle ground, allowing for ease of use without sacrificing the visual appeal of your outdoor space. They are particularly popular in regions with fluctuating weather conditions or where a pool is used year-round with varying environmental challenges.
How do pool screens help with safety and pest control?
Pool screens play a crucial role in enhancing safety by acting as a physical barrier that prevents unauthorized access to the pool. This is especially important for families with young children or pets, as the screen can reduce the risk of accidental drownings when the pool is not in use. Unlike traditional fencing, pool screens also provide a visual boundary that keeps the pool area contained while still being aesthetically pleasing and functional for everyday use.
In terms of pest control, pool screens effectively keep out mosquitoes, flies, and other insects that are commonly drawn to water sources. This helps create a more enjoyable and comfortable environment for swimmers and those lounging nearby. Some screens are even treated with insect-repellent properties or designed with tighter mesh weaves to enhance their effectiveness. Together, these safety and pest control benefits make pool screens a valuable asset for any outdoor pool area.
What materials are commonly used in high-quality pool screening systems?
High-quality pool screens are typically made from a combination of durable mesh fabric and sturdy aluminum or vinyl-coated frames. The mesh is often constructed from woven polyethylene or polyester yarns that are coated to resist UV degradation, mold, and mildew. These materials ensure long-lasting performance, even under extreme weather conditions. The frames are usually made of aluminum alloys that provide strength without adding excessive weight, making installation and operation easier.
Additionally, some advanced screening systems incorporate innovative features such as anti-reflective surfaces for better visibility, reinforced seams for added durability, and weather-resistant zippers or fasteners. The type of material selected will influence the overall cost, lifespan, and maintenance requirements of the screen. Investing in a reputable brand with quality-tested materials will ensure your pool enclosure performs well over time and offers reliable protection against environmental elements.
How much do pool screens typically cost, and are they worth the investment?
The cost of pool screens can vary significantly depending on the type, size, and materials used. Basic retractable models may start around $1,000 to $2,000, while more complex or customized permanent enclosures can run into the tens of thousands. Factors such as the pool’s shape, the need for professional installation, and additional features like automatic retraction or enhanced UV protection can also influence the final price.
Despite the initial expense, pool screens are generally considered a worthwhile investment. They significantly reduce ongoing pool maintenance costs by keeping out debris and reducing chemical evaporation. They also provide health benefits by blocking harmful UV rays and minimizing insect presence, contributing to a safer and more enjoyable swimming environment. Over time, the cost savings and lifestyle improvements often far outweigh the upfront price, making pool screens a smart choice for many homeowners.
Can I install a pool screen myself, or should I hire a professional?
Some pool screens, particularly retractable or portable models, are designed for DIY installation and come with user-friendly kits and instructions. These systems typically require basic tools and moderate mechanical skills, making them accessible to homeowners who are comfortable with installation projects. However, the complexity of the installation largely depends on the type of screen, the shape of your pool, and the existing structure of your patio or lanai.
Professional installation is often recommended for fixed enclosures, custom shapes, or larger pool areas that require more structural support. Experienced installers can ensure a secure and properly fitted screen that meets safety standards and integrates seamlessly with your outdoor space. While hiring a professional adds to the initial cost, it can save time and potential repair issues down the road by ensuring the enclosure is installed correctly. It’s best to assess your skill level and the specific requirements of the screen before deciding between DIY and professional installation.